Tallys Tap & Eatery in Waukesha

Tallys Tap & Eatery in Waukesha
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

S31W24661 Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189-7014, Waukesha

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Pub

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Can you get fish fry carry out?

Absolutely every Friday per Wisconsin law! Lol

Does tallys serve breakfast on the weekends

I belive so. I've never been there for it though.

Do you take reservations on Friday night?

Just walk in

Do you serve breakfast?

Breakfast on the weekends only, I believe

Do they serve Friday lunch fish fry?

I believe they do!

How is the breakfast?

I haven't had their breakfast, sorry

Is there a gluten free menu?

I think yes

Is there pool/darts here?

Darts yes. It's near the front entrance.

can you make a reservation on fridays?

Yes

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Tallys Tap & Eatery
RE
Robert Edwards
google
11.06.2024
4/5

Great fish fry. Staff was super nice and

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JF
Jodylynn Fredricks
google
10.21.2018
3/5

Just want to say we frequent the resteraunt because we normally love both the food and the experience. We were unfortunately extremely disappointed with our recent visit. Our food was incorrect and the server argued over whose fault it was when she was corrected. After it came back out it was burnt. We normally are served quite promptly hence the reason we stopped as we were on our way to a wedding ceremony. So no time for any more corrections but had to settle. Very dissapointed

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AC
Angela Csedo
google
10.10.2018
5/5

Love Tallys aAlways!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AW
Ashlee Waarvik
google
09.25.2018
5/5

This place is huge and has great food! Definitely the best bar in the area

Tallys Tap & Eatery
RB
Regina BelmontWI
google
08.21.2018
5/5

Great food,fast service, and reasonable prices.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AS
Avito Saghu
google
07.23.2018
5/5

I don't usually write reviews. The food was awesome!! The spiral parmesan fries were just outstanding, and I am not that big on fries. I look forward to going there for a Bucks game again soon!!! Good service, clean, nice environment. Food pictures here tell the story!!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
PS
Patricia Sherrer
google
07.21.2018
5/5

I recently moved to Waukesha and Tally's was recommended as a good place to eat. It was very good. Since it was a Friday, I had a perch fry. It was delicious and you have a choice of several sides. I will definitely go there again.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MD
Michele Dundon
google
06.24.2018
5/5

This place has gone made food . Always good service. It’s great “!!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
PD
Pat Doran
google
06.18.2018
5/5

Another gem of Waukesha. Great food and service. The staff is friendly and went the extra mile to help entertain our kiddo while we waited for a table. We had wings, they had a great selection of sauces and the ones we picked were quite delicious.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
NP
Nicholas Pfeiffer
google
06.16.2018
5/5

I highly recommend this place to anyone who is looking for a place to hang out with friends and eat. The building is well lit inside and out and has a very comfortable atmosphere. The service is 10/10 and the prices are fair. As soon as we were seated, a waitress was ready to take our orders and was very attentive to checking in on us throughout our stay to ensure that we had all that we needed. The food was all fresh, hot, and delicious. There was a mixup with my sandwich but they took it back and made a fresh one for me immediately and offered me soup or fries while I waited. I will be coming back soon.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
T&
Tom & Karin
google
05.15.2018
2/5

Stopped there last summer for a later afternoon lunch. The place had a decent crowd for that time of the day and the place looked like it was well cared for. We each had a sandwich and a drink and the food was ho-hum typical bar food. It was not bad but it's not on my top 25 places to go.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MT
Max Tollefson
google
05.05.2018
5/5

Favorite place to go when we don't want to cook dinner. The service is great and everyone is friendly

Tallys Tap & Eatery
CP
Cesar Perez
google
04.09.2018
5/5

Went with others for the wing special, noce atmosphere and right off of sunset.... I'm vegan so the fries were good 😅 I noticed they have the impossible burger after the fact... a little pricey but it's that or fries 😂🌱

Tallys Tap & Eatery
EE
Erin Esser
google
03.26.2018
5/5

Food was incredible!!! The staff was super nice. Such a cute and inviting place for good food!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
KW
Kimberly Wellhausen
google
03.09.2018
4/5

Good fish fry and drinks, but the beer selection isn't great.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
SM
Suzane Moore
google
02.25.2018
4/5

Awesome BLT steak salad. The Kale and sausage soup was excellent with just the right amount of zip!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MS
Mark Schlegel
google
02.06.2018
5/5

Great food, great atmosphere. Good choice for a casual afternoon or evening.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MK
Michael Kasala
google
01.22.2018
3/5

Food was good, service at the bar was good.Wanted to sit down in the dinning area. We were told that it was an hour wait, which I did not understand since there were many tables open, cleaned and set. Didn't make sense to me.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
BL
Bruce Lawson
google
01.16.2018
4/5

Ordered perch, got the AYCE cod. Got all confused when I was offered more fish.Good beer choices.Also listed as Tallingers restaurant and lounge

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AC
Alyssa Carter
google
11.13.2017
5/5

Always great food, drinks, and service when we visit. Friday night in particular I had the baked cod dinner which was delicious and not fishy at all, cooked perfectly! It came with melted butter and horseradish sauce which complemented well. My husband had the build your own grilled cheese on texas toast which he thoroughly enjoyed. They always have food and drink specials on different days and you'll never have a bad meal here. The servers are awesome! We'll definitely return for more delicious meals!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
TD
Tricia Dombrowski
google
10.01.2017
5/5

I stopped in here a bit later in the night just maybe less than 30 minutes before the kitchen closed. I was with my teenage daughter. The menu shocked me because it was that great! There are some very unique items on it and all sounded so good. The service was amazing and the food was outstanding. I can't say enough good things about our experience here! We'll definitely be going back!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
TH
Ted Harbaugh
google
09.26.2017
5/5

Great food and great service. Went here to try the wings and was not disappointed. Definitely some of the best wings in the area. Lots of delicious sauce choices and I was given the opportunity to sample the sauces before ordering which was much appreciated. Can't wait to go back and try the giant nachos and giant stuffed pretzels.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JS
Jeremy Schultz
google
09.07.2017
5/5

My wife and I having been loving this place since we started going here about 3 years ago. We usually go for a quick dinner during the week on one of their two wing nights. This week we took some friends that had never been her before on Saturday night at about 5. Everyone loved the food. I got the prime rib and it was excellent. There is always some sort of drink and food special for the day. One of our favorite spots, and the staff is great!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
SP
Sarah P
google
08.25.2017
5/5

We arrived around 6pm on a Friday, found the only parking spot available. Wait was around 30 minutes. We didn't wait long for drinks at the bar. My husband was not impressed by the Old Fashioned. Fish fry was delicious, potato pancakes were crispy, served with maple syrup and apple sauce. Maple syrup goes surprisingly well with fish!? Who knew! Service was excellent, even with a packed house.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
DC
Demetria Chojnacki
google
07.17.2017
5/5

My family loves Tally's! Everyone once in awhile they have a meat raffle and other fun events. They can get pretty crowded but that's because they have awesome food. They make their own soups IN HOUSE not from some bag of frozen slop. Their crispy chicken sandwiches are my favorite and we also like their stuffed pretzels. Give them a try!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
DW
Dave Wiese
google
06.18.2017
3/5

Nice folks working there, food was ok. I ordered a burger "medium" and it was definitely well done. If you're gonna make a burger well done, don't ask how we want them.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
CK
Carol Kempke
google
06.15.2017
5/5

Potato skins we're out of this world. My thanks to the chef

Tallys Tap & Eatery
hp
heather promo
google
06.14.2017
5/5

Love this place! Great food and awesome smoking deck!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AW
Alison Worm
google
06.08.2017
5/5

Food is excellent! Such a huge menu, we're going to have to go back several times to try everything we saw that interested us!! Great selection of tap beers and they even have drink and food specials on Saturday nights! Cute little place, great service, definitely recommend!!! Oh and Karaoke on Sat nights!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JL
Jorge Lopez
google
05.16.2017
4/5

Great food first time definitely will be back the fish fry looks amazing

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MP
M P
google
05.14.2017
5/5

Great place to meet up with friends and hear some live music. The food is really good. I had the grilled cheese and would definitely have it again (though the raw onions are thickly cut and strong). The service is professional and kind. The location is ideal, being close to Milwaukee, but still far from the traffic. There is plenty of available parking around the building for free. The interior of the building is well lit and nicely decorated. Very clean. I would recommend this place for meeting up with family and friends (even children are welcome! This is not a bar/pub atmosphere) and perhaps see if they could cater for a smallish party. Just be aware that it gets very loud on their busy nights. All in all, I would highly recommend Tally's Tap and Eatery.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
LH
Layne Hanson
google
04.04.2017
5/5

I always stop buying some food in this place. I liked the rapid service and well prepared food. They never disappoint.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
ZC
Zeke C
google
03.10.2017
5/5

This place is great. Smoking room in the back. All enclosed smoking room!! Awesome food. Friendly staff. My favorite bar in Waukesha.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JO
Jason Ohm
google
02.17.2017
5/5

Friendly staff and great food. Drink selection is good as well.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
BV
Bonnie Von Rueden
google
02.06.2017
5/5

Always great food!! Friday night is always packed but worth the wait!!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
KM
Kory M
google
01.25.2017
5/5

Tallys and the ownership have done wonderful things in terms of upgrades and events. Always something fun going down at Tallys Tap! They also sponsor a lot of sports teams and have an absolutely top notch staff! Food is awesome too, including their TACO TUESDAY specials!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
SO
Sarah Olson
google
01.03.2017
5/5

Tally's is a great place to stop for a drink after work or a delicious meal. They even have a "back bar" where you can smoke inside. Took my mom there for dinner for the first time and ordered the Garlic & Parmesan Tally Fries for her... She tried them and said it's now one of her new favorite places to eat. The service was impeccable and the staff were all super friendly. The only downside is that if it's crowded and you're there for a meal, rather than just drinks at the bar, it can be loud and you have to raise your voice to be heard across the table, but that's fairly typical for a bar atmosphere.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
SR
Steph Rhone
google
11.24.2016
5/5

One of the reviews said its usually a long wait. We were seated as soon as we walked in and it was a Saturday late afternoon at that. This was our first visit. We are from out of state working in Milwaukee and we love trying different places throughout our travels. Our waitress was excellent and the food was fantastic and plentiful. This is one place that is saved in my google maps to return while I am here. I Definitely recommend Tallys Tap & Eatery.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JP
John Patrick
google
11.24.2016
5/5

I have been to Tallys about a dozen times and have always had a great experience. I even brought 4 year old and 1 year old in for lunch on the weekend a couple times and they were very accommodating. Great food, great beer selection and (laugh if you will, but it's important) clean bathrooms make Tallys one if my favorite places to kick back.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
DK
David Krueger
google
11.24.2016
5/5

The lunch we ordered was fast and tasty. We went with appetizers and sandwiches.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
bd
brian delorenzo
google
10.25.2016
3/5

I was torn between a 3 star and 4 star review. They have good bar food and the bartenders were great. Lots of TVs for watching the game. There were several drawbacks, though. We ordered wings and got all paddles. Not one drumstick. How does that happen? On purpose, obviously. Every side costs extra. Our server asked us if we wanted celery and carrots with the wings, without telling us that they were extra $$. We got 3 bits of celery, and 3 carrots for $1.50. Cheese for the pretzel was $1.75. Yikes. It's not going to break the bank, but it's still nice to know. Lame.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
JE
Joanne Eckman
google
10.09.2016
5/5

Pizza pretzel was delish Cant wait to come back

Tallys Tap & Eatery
CL
Craig Lopacinski
google
09.26.2016
5/5

Worked very hard during the quarantine and it showed. Very good pub food. Wing special on Monday and Thursdays. Also try the giant pretzels.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
PG
Paul Gorzalski
google
06.25.2016
5/5

Fantastic burgers and Mercedes was great. Thank you Tallys!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
KH
Kris Hansen
google
06.16.2016
5/5

Excellent breakfast, other food is excellent. Can get a little noisy at times. Great service

Tallys Tap & Eatery
SP
Simon Prosser
google
05.09.2016
4/5

Solid 4-star local Waukesha bar. Bright but decent atmosphere. Food was good for the most part. Stuffed pretzel wasn't much liked but everything else was good. Decent beer selection. Standard beers but enough craft options to cater to everyone. Waited a long time for service on a Tuesday evening, hence the one star off, but otherwise wouldn't hesitate to come back here.

Tallys Tap & Eatery
AS
Angela Stapleton
google
03.20.2016
5/5

The food is out of this world delicious and creative. The service was friendly and quick so I definitely recommend it!

Tallys Tap & Eatery
ss
sherry spellman
google
02.21.2016
5/5

Great all you can eat fish fry and homemade potato pancakes

Tallys Tap & Eatery
DM
Dave McWilliams
google
01.15.2016
5/5

Great food with even better wait staff. Our server was amazing. Very polite & sweet as can be.We have become somewhat regulars & highly recommend asking for server by name: We request "Mercedes" whenever possible. (This one is quite special)👏😄👏

Tallys Tap & Eatery
MC
Marty Christensen
google
01.01.2016
5/5

Delicious day and night. Daily specials for lunch, dinner. Wings -- oh wow . A must get again. Bands play often at night, darts ...

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12624463153

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!